150 YEARS STRONG

15 Years of Fear: ALA and the Patriot Act

October 26, 2001, marked the beginning of a 15-year-long struggle for the privacy rights of library users as a result of the USA PATRIOT Act being signed into law by President Bush. The Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act, colloquially known as the Patriot Act, expanded surveillance and investigation capabilities of law enforcement to combat terrorism after the attack on September 11th.[1] Included in the bill was Section 215, which became known as the “library provision” as it allowed intelligence agencies to “obtain information about members of the public, including library records, based on a minimal submission to a secret court.”[2]

USA PATRIOT Act files in the Office for Intellectual Freedom Subject File at the ALA Archives.
USA PATRIOT Act files in the Office for Intellectual Freedom Subject File at the ALA Archives.

Prompted by the immediate possibility of government agents ordering libraries to turn over patron information, the American Library Conference (ALA) Washington Office created the “Guidelines for Librarians on the U.S.A. PATRIOT Act: What to do before, during and after a ‘knock at the door?’” which provided guidance on consulting legal counsel and reviewing policies.[3] Librarians largely opposed the Patriot Act as it “eliminate[d] the due process and probable cause protections guaranteed by the Constitution to library users.”[4] This meant the FBI and other government agents could demand patron information, such as records of books borrowed. To protect patron confidentiality, libraries adopted the common practice of only temporarily holding onto patron records. This angered government officials like former U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft, who claimed librarians had been persuaded to mistrust the government through “breathless reports and baseless hysteria.”[5] However, as former ALA president Maurice J. Freedman explained, librarians are trusted by their patrons and committed to confidentiality and privacy rights.[6] Section 215 of the Patriot Act, for many librarians, was an abuse of power in the name of national security.

The ALA additionally opposed the National Security Letter power given to law enforcement by the Patriot Act, which allowed “government agents to obtain sensitive information about innocent Americans without any court order.”[7] Government agents could impose a gag order upon recipients of these requests, such as librarians and booksellers, prohibiting them from informing patrons and colleagues about these investigations.[8]

Figure from the Office of the Inspector General shows approved Section 215 orders, 2007-2015.
Figure from the Office of the Inspector General shows approved Section 215 orders, 2007-2015. From the ALA Archives.

One such investigation hit close to home for former ALA President Carol Brey-Casiano in early 2002. Working as director of the El Paso (Texas) Public Library, Brey-Casiano was approached by Texas Rangers who demanded that computer sign-up sheets be handed over as evidence for an investigation into a suspicious threat sent from a library computer.[9] She told the Rangers they would need a court order to access patron records. One of the Rangers attempted to invoke the Patriot Act’s authority, which Brey-Casiano refused due to the Rangers being state, not federal, law enforcement agents. When the court order was produced the following day, the sign-up sheets had already been shredded, which regularly happened every night. Brey-Casiano was subjected to an official investigation due to her actions and was ordered not to discuss the investigation by the mayor. She consulted with a lawyer and applied for assistance from the Merritt Humanitarian Fund to pay the fees associated with the case.[10] The Leroy C. Merritt Humanitarian Fund provides aid to librarians who are discriminated against or denied employment rights because of their defense of intellectual freedom.

Eventually, after police interviewed her entire staff and intense isolation due to the gag order, the charges against Brey-Casiano for withholding information were dropped.[11] There is no knowing how many librarians were approached in similar ways over the years of the Patriot Act’s existence. There were multiple hundreds of Section 215 orders approved by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court from 2002-2015, and tens of thousands of NSLs issued by the FBI. Government reports do not reveal the number of these orders given to libraries.[12]

Carol Brey-Casiano at the 2005 ALA Annual Conference. From the ALA Archives.
Carol Brey-Casiano speaks at the 2005 ALA Annual Conference. From the ALA Archives.

Section 215 did not expire until June 1, 2015, despite the continued efforts by the ALA and other library associations to speak out about the threat by government mass surveillance to constitutional rights, patron privacy, and freedom of access to information.[13] The section was revised slightly in 2006 but continued to be included in extensions of the Patriot Act in 2009 and 2011. It wasn’t until the sunsetting in 2015 and the passage of the USA Freedom Act, which the ALA saw as “the first meaningful reform of our surveillance laws in almost 15 years,” that librarians and library users could feel free of the dangers of Section 215.[14] While there is still more work to be done on ensuring patron privacy and intellectual freedom, the limitation of Section 215 and the National Security Letter powers of the federal government marked the end of ALA’s lengthy struggle against government mass surveillance of library records.

Sources

[1] “USA PATRIOT Act,” American Library Association, May 29, 2020, https://www.ala.org/advocacy/patriot-act.

[2] “Library Associations Statement On The USA PATRIOT Amendments Act of 2009,” American Library Association, Association of Research Libraries, October 29, 2009, https://www.ala.org/sites/default/files/advocacy/content/advleg/federallegislation/theusapatriotact/house-jud-1pgrpsaFINAL%2010%2029%2009.pdf.

[3] January 19, 2002, https://www.ala.org/sites/default/files/advocacy/content/advleg/federallegislation/theusapatriotact/patstep.pdf.

[4] Maurice J. Freedman, “Librarians fight to protect your privacy,” The Journal News, September 19, 2003, Maurice J. (Mitch) Freedman Papers, 1996-2005, Record Series 2/1/44, Box 15, Folder 9: “Librarians fight to protect your privacy,” The Journal News Op Ed 9/19/2003, American Library Association Archives at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

[5] John Ashcroft, “The Proven Tactics in the Fight against Crime,” prepared remarks for the National Restaurant Association, Washington, D.C., September 15, 2003, https://www.justice.gov/archive/ag/speeches/2003/091503nationalrestaurant.htm.

[6] Freedman, “Librarians fight to protect.”

[7] “Library Associations Statement.”

[8] Maryland Library Association Intellectual Freedom Panel 2017, Intellectual Freedom Manual (Maryland Library Association, 2017), The USA PATRIOT Act and Libraries, 17-19, https://www.mdlib.org/files/docs/divisions/ifap/patriotact.pdf.

[9] “Carol Brey-Casiano Tells a Patriot Act Story,” American Libraries, June 29, 2010, https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blogs/the-scoop/carol-brey-casiano-tells-a-patriot-act-story/.

[10] For more information, consult LeRoy C. Merritt Humanitarian Fund Correspondence, 1970-2010, Record Series 6/5/5, Box 2, Folder: 2002, Carol Brey, American Library Association Archives at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

[11] “Carol Brey-Casiano Tells a Patriot Act Story.”

[12] U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General, “A Review of the FBI’s Use of Section 215 Orders for Business Records in 2012 through 2014,” September 29, 2016, https://oig.justice.gov/reports/review-fbis-use-section-215-orders-business-records-2012-through-2014.

“Surveillance Under the Patriot Act,” American Civil Liberties Union, accessed October 2, 2024, https://www.aclu.org/issues/national-security/privacy-and-surveillance/surveillance-under-patriot-act.

[13] “ALA cheers expiration of intrusive Patriot Act provision,” American Libraries, June 1, 2015, https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/blogs/the-scoop/ala-cheers-expiration-of-intrusive-patriot-act-provision/.

[14] American Library Association, “ALA calls passage of USA FREEDOM Act a ‘milestone,’” news release, June 2, 2015, https://www.ala.org/news/2015/06/ala-calls-passage-usa-freedom-act-milestone.

 

This story first appeared on the ALA Archives blog on October 7, 2024.

150 YEARS STRONG

THE OFFICIAL ANNIVERSARY BLOG

ALA Library War Service book plate design draft.

Reading for the Future: Looking Back on the Library War Service and 150 Years of ALA

In 1919, Herbert Hoover founded the Hoover War Library at Stanford University in response to the devastation he witnessed in Europe. Today, as archivists at the Hoover Institution Library & Archives, we encounter many collections related to World War I, but the dynamic photographs of librarians distributing reading materials to soldiers in our American Library Association War Service records caught our attention and led us on an unexpected and informative journey.

Stationary used by George Nason with “Association” blotted out. From the ALA Archives,

The Curious Case of the Two American Library Associations

In 1899, the American Library Association was notified that a small commercial traveling library was operating under the name “The American Library Association” under the tutelage of “a person of questionable character and unsavory reputation.” Thus began the curious case of the two American Library Associations.

The exterior of the McCormick Mansion. An inconvenient office space or a mansion overrun by ghosts? From the ALA Archives.

Was ALA’s McCormick Mansion Haunted?

Halloween is approaching and during this spooky season, the ALA Archives has been meditating upon one of ALA’s old headquarters, the McCormick Mansion. Why would ALA want to move out of the McCormick Mansion so quickly and destroy it? Was it because the mansion was … haunted?

USA PATRIOT Act files in the Office for Intellectual Freedom Subject File at the ALA Archives.

15 Years of Fear: ALA and the Patriot Act

October 26, 2001, marked the beginning of a 15-year-long struggle for the privacy rights of library users as a result of the USA PATRIOT Act being signed into law by President Bush. Prompted by the possibility of government agents ordering libraries to turn over patron information, ALA’s Washington Office created the “Guidelines for Librarians on the U.S.A. PATRIOT Act: What to do before, during and after a ‘knock at the door?’” which provided guidance on consulting legal counsel and reviewing policies.

A group of foreign delegates in Atlantic City during the ALA Fiftieth Anniversary Conference, October 1926.

Librarians Go on a Road Trip! The 1926 Foreign Delegate Post-Conference Excursion

In early October 1926, almost 60 librarians from 25 countries gathered in Atlantic City and Philadelphia to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the American Library Association along with more than 2,000 American librarians. By all accounts, the conference was a great success. But the best part of this all-expenses-paid trip to the U.S. didn’t happen during the actual meeting: When the conference ended, about 30 international delegates went on a multi-state excursion, visiting 12 cities in the span of two weeks.

How I Library podcast with Betty Turock

Celebrating ALA’s Birthday in Conversation with Dr. Betty Turock

In a special episode of the “How I Library” podcast commemorating the 150th anniversary of the American Library Association, show host and I Love Libraries editor Phil Morehart speaks with one of the key figures in the history of the Association and librarianship, Dr. Betty Turock.